Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Reishi Ganoderma lucidumImmune
Evaluation of Immune Modulation by β-1,3;1,6 D-Glucan Derived from Ganoderma lucidum in Healthy Adult Volunteers
Chen SN et al. · Foods · 2023
Population: Healthy adults 18–55, double-blind placebo-controlled, 84 days
The reishi beta-glucan group showed a significant increase in immune cell populations (CD3, CD4) versus placebo; the product was well tolerated.
Goal:
Surrogate immune markers rather than clinical endpoints; a single medium-sized trial.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Reishi Ganoderma lucidumImmune
Ganoderma lucidum supplementation modulates T lymphocyte function in older women
Iser-Bem PN et al. · British Journal of Nutrition · 2024
Population: 39 older women, 2000 mg/day extract, 8 weeks
The extract increased lymphocyte proliferation and expression of immune/regulatory genes (FoxP3, TGF-β, IL-10, IL-6).
Goal:
Small sample; ex-vivo laboratory markers rather than clinical outcomes.
Animal studyReishi Ganoderma lucidumImmune · Gut
Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharide modulates gut microbiota and immune cell function in colon
Guo C et al. · Carbohydrate Polymers · 2021
Population: Mouse model (colitis-associated cancer)
The polysaccharide reduced inflammation and tumor burden, corrected microbiome dysbiosis and increased short-chain fatty acids; it suppressed TLR4/NF-κB.
Goal:
Preclinical; not tested in humans.
Animal studyReishi Ganoderma lucidumImmune · Cancer
Ganoderma lucidum Polysaccharide Activates T-Cell Antitumor Immunity and Enhances Anti-PD-1 Efficacy in Colorectal Cancer
Li W et al. · J Agric Food Chem · 2024
Population: Mouse colorectal cancer model
The polysaccharide increased CD8/Th1 cells, reduced Tregs and improved the efficacy of anti-PD-1 immunotherapy.
Goal:
Preclinical only; hypothesis-generating regarding combination with immunotherapy.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewReishi Ganoderma lucidumCancer (adjunct)
Ganoderma lucidum (Reishi mushroom) for cancer treatment
Jin X et al. · Cochrane Database Syst Rev · 2016
Population: 5 randomized trials in cancer patients
Adding reishi to chemo/radiotherapy increased the likelihood of response (RR 1.50, CI 0.90–2.51) with a slight rise in immune markers; well tolerated, no survival data.
Goal:
Authors' conclusion: insufficient evidence for use as a first-line treatment; study quality was "inadequate".
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewReishi Ganoderma lucidumCancer
Medicinal Mushroom Supplements in Cancer: A Systematic Review of Clinical Studies
Narayanan S et al. · Current Oncology Reports · 2023
Population: 39 clinical studies (12 mushroom preparations)
Signals for quality of life/survival were found for some preparations; the evidence specific to Ganoderma is limited and mixed.
Goal:
The strongest survival signals actually came from other mushrooms (Huaier, PSK).
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Reishi Ganoderma lucidumCancer
Preliminary Efficacy and Safety of Reishi & Privet Formula on Quality of Life in NSCLC Patients Undergoing Chemotherapy
Liu J et al. · Integr Cancer Ther · 2020
Population: 82 NSCLC lung cancer patients, formula 3.36 g/day, 6 weeks, phase II
A phase II trial examining quality of life (FACT-L) and safety of a reishi-based formula during chemotherapy; well tolerated.
Goal:
Preliminary, small, a combination formula (not reishi alone); surrogate endpoints.
Study protocolReishi Ganoderma lucidumCancer
De-walled Ganoderma lucidum spore powder synergy with targeted therapy in EGFR-mutant NSCLC (protocol)
Wu TT et al. · BMC Complement Med Ther · 2024
Population: Planned n=140 NSCLC patients on osimertinib, 56 days
A protocol for a planned randomized trial testing whether reishi spore powder reduces fatigue and adds efficacy; no results yet.
Goal:
Protocol only — no outcome data; included to flag ongoing human research.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Reishi Ganoderma lucidumMetabolic · Lipids
Clinical Evaluation of Ganoderma lucidum Spore Oil for Triglyceride Reduction
Wang X et al. · Nutrients · 2025
Population: 110 adults with dyslipidemia, spore oil, 12 weeks, crossover
The group receiving the preparation showed a significant reduction in total cholesterol, triglycerides and LDL and an increase in HDL versus placebo.
Goal:
A single trial; an industry-adjacent supplement; lacking independent replication.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewReishi Ganoderma lucidumMetabolic · Cardiac
Ganoderma lucidum mushroom for the treatment of cardiovascular risk factors
Klupp NL et al. · Cochrane Database Syst Rev · 2015
Population: 5 trials, 398 participants (mostly type 2 diabetes), 12–16 weeks
Reishi was not associated with a significant reduction in HbA1c, cholesterol, LDL or BMI; the evidence does not support use for cardiovascular risk factors.
Goal:
A key negative finding. Slightly more (non-serious) side effects than placebo (RR 1.67).
Animal studyReishi Ganoderma lucidumLiver
Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharide inhibits HSC activation and liver fibrosis via TGF-β/Smad
Chen C et al. · Phytomedicine · 2022
Population: Mouse liver fibrosis model + cells
The polysaccharide reduced liver fibrosis and inflammation and inhibited hepatic stellate cell activation via TLR4/NF-κB and TGF-β/Smad.
Goal:
Preclinical; no human liver data.
Animal studyReishi Ganoderma lucidumMetabolic · Vascular
Polysaccharide peptide (PsP) of Ganoderma lucidum: vascular repair in type 2 diabetes model
Heriansyah T et al. · Vasc Health Risk Manag · 2019
Population: 35 Wistar rats, diabetes model
PsP dose-dependently improved endothelial progenitor cell markers and lowered triglycerides, cholesterol and insulin resistance.
Goal:
Rodent model; the authors note that clinical trials are needed.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Reishi Ganoderma lucidumSleep · Fatigue
Placebo-Controlled Crossover Trial of Botanical Agents for Gulf War Illness (incl. Reishi)
Younger J et al. · Int J Environ Res Public Health · 2021
Population: 29 men with Gulf War Illness, pseudo-randomized crossover
A screening trial comparing placebo to various doses of reishi (and two botanicals) on symptom severity, pain and fatigue.
Goal:
A very small, exploratory screening design meant to prioritize agents, not to confirm efficacy.
Animal studyReishi Ganoderma lucidumSleep
Sedative-hypnotic compounds shared by five medicinal Polyporales mushrooms (metabolomics)
Chen W et al. · Phytomedicine · 2024
Population: Mouse sleep model + chemical profiling
Six triterpenes (ganoderic and ganoderenic acids) were identified as the main shared sedative/hypnotic components, including in reishi.
Goal:
Mechanistic/preclinical; no human sleep outcomes.
Animal studyReishi Ganoderma lucidumSleep
Sedative-hypnotic effects of a Ganoderma-containing herbal formulation in mice
Chen W et al. · Phytomedicine · 2025
Population: Mouse models
A three-herb extract containing Ganoderma produced dose-dependent sedation linked to enhanced GABA and cAMP/PKA/CREB/BDNF signaling.
Goal:
A multi-herb formula (not reishi alone), preclinical only.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Lion's mane Hericium erinaceusCognition
Improvement of cognitive functions by oral intake of Hericium erinaceus
Saitsu Y et al. · Biomedical Research (Tokyo) · 2019
Population: Healthy adults, 12 weeks (fruiting body), multicenter
MMSE scores improved/were maintained versus placebo; Benton and verbal-pairing tests did not reach significance.
Goal:
Only 1 of 3 cognitive tests was positive; sample size and demographics were not reported in the abstract.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Lion's mane Hericium erinaceusCognition · Mood
Acute and Chronic Effects of Lion's Mane on Cognitive Function, Stress and Mood in Young Adults (pilot)
Docherty S et al. · Nutrients · 2023
Population: 41 healthy adults 18–45, 1.8 g/day, acute (60 min) + 28 days
Faster Stroop performance 60 min after a dose (p=0.005); a non-significant trend toward reduced subjective stress after 28 days (p=0.051).
Goal:
The authors explicitly note null findings and a small sample; defined as preliminary.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Lion's mane Hericium erinaceusCognition · Mood
Acute effects of a standardised Hericium erinaceus extract on cognition and mood in healthy younger adults
Surendran G et al. · Frontiers in Nutrition · 2025
Population: 18 adults 18–35, single 3 g dose (10:1 extract), crossover
No significant effect on global cognition or mood; only an isolated improvement on a psychomotor (pegboard) test at minute 90.
Goal:
A largely negative acute trial; very small n, a single dose only.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Lion's mane Hericium erinaceusCognition
Acute Effects of Guayusa Tea and Nordic Lion's Mane Extracts on Cognitive Performance
La Monica MB et al. · Nutrients · 2023
Population: Healthy adults, single 1 g dose of lion's mane, crossover
Lion's mane improved working memory, complex attention and reaction time two hours later versus baseline, as well as self-rated happiness.
Goal:
A single acute dose, small n; lion's mane was the secondary variable (guayusa showed broader effects).
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Lion's mane Hericium erinaceusAlzheimer's
Prevention of Early Alzheimer's by Erinacine A-Enriched Hericium erinaceus Mycelia (pilot)
Li IC et al. · Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience · 2020
Population: Mild Alzheimer's patients, erinacine A-enriched mycelium 1050 mg/day, 49 weeks
The supplement group showed improvement in MMSE, IADL and contrast sensitivity versus placebo, alongside neurological biomarker/imaging trends.
Goal:
A small pilot; funded and conducted by the manufacturer (Grape King Bio); 4 dropouts due to digestive/skin effects.
Literature reviewLion's mane Hericium erinaceusMood · Depression
Therapeutic Potential of Hericium erinaceus for Depressive Disorder
Chong PS et al. · Int J Mol Sci · 2019
Population: Review (preclinical + limited human data)
Summarizes proposed mechanisms for antidepressant action (neurogenesis, BDNF/NGF, anti-inflammatory, gut-brain axis) and preliminary human signals.
Goal:
A narrative review; the human antidepressant evidence is sparse and preliminary.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewLion's mane Hericium erinaceusMood
Edible and Medicinal Fungi as Candidate Natural Antidepressants
Gong P et al. · Mol Nutr Food Res · 2025
Population: Systematic review of edible/medicinal mushrooms
Reports that mushroom extracts modulate 5-HT/dopamine systems and reduce depression-like symptoms; lion's mane is among the highlighted species.
Goal:
Mechanistic/preclinical emphasis; not a clinical meta-analysis specific to lion's mane.
Literature reviewLion's mane Hericium erinaceusNeural · Mechanism
Neurotrophic and Neuroprotective Effects of Hericium erinaceus
Szućko-Kociuba I et al. · Int J Mol Sci · 2023
Population: Review
Reviews evidence that erinacines/hericenones stimulate NGF release, reduce oxidative stress and inflammation and protect neurons from apoptosis.
Goal:
A mechanistic review; the effects are mostly from cell/animal models.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewLion's mane Hericium erinaceusNeural · Mechanism
Erinacines in the neuroprotective effects of Hericium erinaceus: a systematic review in preclinical models
Spangenberg ET et al. · Frontiers in Pharmacology · 2025
Population: Systematic review — cell and rodent models
Erinacines (mainly A and C) show dose-dependent antioxidant (Nrf2), anti-inflammatory and pro-neurogenic effects with cognitive/behavioral benefit.
Goal:
Explicitly preclinical only; no human outcomes.
Animal studyLion's mane Hericium erinaceusNeural
Hericium erinaceus Improves Recognition Memory and Induces Neurogenesis in Frail Aging Mice
Ratto D et al. · Nutrients · 2019
Population: Aged/frail mice, standardized extract for two months
Reversed age-related decline in recognition memory and increased neurogenesis markers in the hippocampus and cerebellum (PCNA, DCX).
Goal:
Animals only; not yet demonstrated in humans.
Animal studyLion's mane Hericium erinaceusNeural
Neuroprotective Metabolites of Hericium erinaceus Promote Neuro-Healthy Aging
Roda E et al. · Int J Mol Sci · 2021
Population: Aged frail mice, standardized extract for two months
Partially restored motor performance and reduced Purkinje neuron loss, inflammation and oxidative stress in the cerebellum.
Goal:
Animals only, mechanistic.
Animal studyLion's mane Hericium erinaceusNeural · Metabolic
Hericium erinaceus Mycelium and Erinacine A Ameliorate Metabolic Dysfunction and Learning Deficits in Aging Mice
Tsai YC et al. · J Med Food · 2019
Population: 15-month-old mice on a high-fat/high-sugar diet, 18 weeks
Improved spatial learning, lowered neuroinflammatory cytokines, raised hippocampal NGF and improved metabolic markers.
Goal:
Animals only; a combined metabolic-cognitive model.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewLion's mane Hericium erinaceusSafety · Review
Benefits, side effects, and uses of Hericium erinaceus as a supplement: a systematic review
Menon A et al. · Frontiers in Nutrition · 2025
Population: 5 RCTs, 3 pilots, 15 laboratory studies, a cohort and a case report
Pooling MMSE from one RCT and one pilot showed a modest weighted increase of ~1.17 points; side effects included abdominal discomfort, headache and allergy.
Goal:
A small pooled human base; the effect size is modest; safety data are often underreported.
Literature reviewLion's mane Hericium erinaceusSafety · ALS
ALSUntangled #73: Lion's Mane
Muhanna M et al. · Amyotroph Lateral Scler Frontotemporal Degener · 2023
Population: Structured assessment (neurodegenerative/ALS context)
Notes plausible mechanisms of neuroprotection/neuron growth, but that clinical human evidence is limited to very small trials; no proven efficacy in ALS.
Goal:
A useful counterweight to marketing claims; flags sparse human data and possible side effects.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Cordyceps CordycepsPerformance · Muscle
Cordyceps accelerates stem cell recruitment to human skeletal muscle after exercise
Dewi L et al. · Food & Function · 2024
Population: 14 young men (~age 24), muscle biopsies after interval training
A single 1 g dose before exercise reduced necrotic cell infiltration and accelerated recruitment of stem cells (CD34+) and satellite cells (Pax7+) in muscle versus placebo.
Goal:
A very small biopsy trial; tissue/cell markers rather than performance (VO2max, strength). A single acute dose.
Literature reviewCordyceps CordycepsPerformance
Ergogenic Aid by Cordyceps: Does It Work?
Dewi L et al. · Current Nutrition Reports · 2025
Population: Review of human trials (mostly young active adults)
Over 2–16 weeks cordyceps improved aerobic performance (time to exhaustion) in what appeared to be a dose-dependent manner, but the effect on aerobic fitness (VO2max) was not consistent.
Goal:
Narrative (not systematic/meta); small underlying trials; older/sedentary populations were understudied.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Cordyceps CordycepsPerformance
Concurrent Training + Multi-Ingredient Supplement (Rhodiola + Cordyceps) in Active Men
Kreipke VC et al. · J Dietary Supplements · 2020
Population: 21 active men, 14-week training program
The combined supplement did not improve body composition, overall training performance or blood biomarkers versus placebo.
Goal:
Combined (cordyceps cannot be isolated), small n; a negative finding — a counterweight to the positive claims.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalCordyceps CordycepsEnergy · Hypoxia
Signal pathways and bioactive compounds of the anti-hypoxia effect of Chinese cordyceps
Long H et al. · J Ethnopharmacol · 2021
Population: Cell and mouse models (network pharmacology)
Showed anti-hypoxia activity, improved cell survival under low-oxygen conditions; the proposed mechanism — VEGF-mediated angiogenesis (linoleic acid and cerevisterol as candidates).
Goal:
Mechanistic/preclinical only; no human data.
Animal studyCordyceps CordycepsFatigue
Cordycepin combined with antioxidant effects improves fatigue caused by excessive exercise
Cheng C et al. · Scientific Reports · 2025
Population: Forced-exercise mouse model + laboratory
Cordycepin increased endurance and liver/muscle glycogen, lowered lactate/LDH/CK, raised SOD and reduced MDA, via Keap1/Nrf2/HO-1 and BDNF.
Goal:
Rodents only; the implication for human performance is unproven.
Literature reviewCordyceps CordycepsFatigue
Natural medicines for the treatment of fatigue: components, pharmacology, mechanisms
Luo C et al. · Pharmacological Research · 2019
Population: Review
Reviews natural anti-fatigue agents including Cordyceps alongside ginseng and rhodiola, and describes mechanisms and active compounds.
Goal:
A narrative review; groups cordyceps with other botanicals; the evidence is mostly mechanistic, with limited human trial data.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewCordyceps CordycepsImmune · Cancer
Adjuvant Cordyceps for lung cancer: systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs
Wang C et al. · J Ethnopharmacol · 2024
Population: 12 RCTs, 928 lung cancer patients
As an adjunct, cordyceps was associated with improved tumor response rate (RR 1.17), higher immune markers (CD4/CD8/NK), better quality of life and fewer side effects; suggested dose 6 g/day.
Goal:
Most of the RCTs were in Chinese with variable/unclear methodological quality; positive but at risk of publication/quality bias.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewCordyceps CordycepsKidney
Cordyceps as adjunctive treatment in hemodialysis patients: systematic review and meta-analysis
Ong BY et al. · J Tradit Chin Med · 2019
Population: 12 RCTs, 655 maintenance dialysis patients
Low-to-moderate quality evidence for improvement in CRP, albumin, MDA and hemoglobin, but not in creatinine or LDL.
Goal:
An explicitly negative bottom line — high heterogeneity, unclear quality; insufficient evidence for routine use.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewCordyceps CordycepsImmune · Cancer
Medicinal Mushroom Supplements in Cancer: A Systematic Review of Clinical Studies
Narayanan S et al. · Current Oncology Reports · 2023
Population: 39 human studies (cordyceps among them)
Various medicinal mushrooms showed a positive effect on chemotherapy toxicity, quality of life and immune response; survival signals were mainly for Huaier and PSK (not specific to cordyceps).
Goal:
The authors conclude that the evidence is not conclusive for routine clinical use; many studies are small/observational.
Literature reviewCordyceps CordycepsImmune
Cordyceps spp.: A Review on Its Immune-Stimulatory and Other Biological Potentials
Das G et al. · Frontiers in Pharmacology · 2021
Population: Review
Summarizes immune-stimulating activity (cytokine induction, phagocytosis, nitric oxide via MAPK) alongside antioxidant, anticancer and renoprotective activity.
Goal:
A review with a preclinical emphasis; the biological activity is mostly from in-vitro/animal studies.
Animal studyCordyceps CordycepsMechanism · Cordycepin
Cordycepin Modulates Microglial M2 Polarization and Mitochondrial Metabolism
Zhong X et al. · Advanced Science · 2024
Population: APP/PS1 Alzheimer's mouse model, microglia
Cordycepin improved cognition/memory in an Alzheimer's model by polarizing microglia to M2 and metabolic reprogramming, with HKII and PDK2 as molecular targets.
Goal:
A preclinical mechanistic study; no human data.
Animal studyCordyceps CordycepsMechanism · Cordycepin
Cordycepin prevents radiation ulcer by inhibiting cell senescence via NRF2 and AMPK
Wang Z et al. · Nature Communications · 2019
Population: Rodent radiation ulcer models
Cordycepin blocked radiation ulcers (skin, intestine, tongue) by inhibiting cellular senescence, via NRF2 and direct AMPK activation.
Goal:
Strong mechanistic evidence in rodents with a defined molecular target; not yet tested clinically for this indication.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Cordyceps CordycepsSafety
Safety Assessment of HEA-Enriched Cordyceps cicadae Mycelium: A Randomized Clinical Trial
Tsai YS et al. · J Am Coll Nutr · 2020
Population: 49 participants, 1.05 g freeze-dried mycelium per day, 3 months
No significant changes in kidney/liver function, electrolytes or lipids over 3 months, and no side effects — supporting short-term safety.
Goal:
A safety endpoint only (no efficacy); small n, 3 months, an industry affiliation; no long-term data.
Literature reviewCordyceps CordycepsKidney
Therapeutic Strategies for Renal Fibrosis: Cordyceps and Related Products
Tan W et al. · Frontiers in Pharmacology · 2022
Population: Review (preclinical + cited clinical trials)
Reviews mechanisms by which cordyceps may act against renal fibrosis (anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, autophagy regulation, less ECM deposition).
Goal:
The authors' caveat — existing clinical studies are low-quality and heterogeneous; large, well-designed RCTs are needed.
Literature reviewChaga Inonotus obliquusGeneral review
Therapeutic properties of Inonotus obliquus (Chaga mushroom): A review
Ern PTY · Mycology · 2023
Population: Narrative review
Summarizes preclinical evidence for anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, anticancer, antidiabetic and hepatoprotective activity attributed to polysaccharides, triterpenoids and polyphenols.
Goal:
The evidence base is laboratory/animal and mechanistic; no human efficacy trials were cited.
Literature reviewChaga Inonotus obliquusGeneral review
Chaga mushroom: a super-fungus with countless facets and untapped potential
Fordjour E · Frontiers in Pharmacology · 2023
Population: Review
Reviews mycochemistry and antioxidant/anti-inflammatory/antitumor activity; notes that most data are in-vitro/animal pharmacology.
Goal:
The authors explicitly note that the benefit is "largely untapped" due to limited human data.
Literature reviewChaga Inonotus obliquusGeneral review
Medicinal and nutraceutical importance of Inonotus obliquus (chaga) mushrooms
Camilleri E · Heliyon · 2024
Population: Review
Catalogs anticancer, antioxidant, antidiabetic, anti-inflammatory and immune-balancing properties and proposed mechanisms.
Goal:
A preclinical synthesis; no evidence from clinical trials.
Literature reviewChaga Inonotus obliquusGlucose · Review
Inonotus obliquus - from folk medicine to clinical use
Szychowski KA · J Tradit Complement Med · 2020
Population: Review
Highlights hypoglycemic/insulin-sensitizing and antioxidant mechanisms (ROS, PPARγ) as the most promising directions.
Goal:
Concludes that studies meeting evidence-based medicine criteria are needed — that is, human evidence is lacking.
Case report (safety)Chaga Inonotus obliquusSafety
Chaga mushroom-induced oxalate nephropathy manifesting as nephrotic syndrome
Kwon O · Medicine (Baltimore) · 2022
Population: 69-year-old man, chaga powder 10–15 g/day + vitamin C, 3 months
Developed acute kidney failure with calcium-oxalate crystal deposition (oxalate nephropathy); required dialysis and steroids, recovered within a month.
Goal:
A safety signal — chaga is high in oxalate; excessive consumption was linked to acute oxalate nephropathy.
Case report (safety)Chaga Inonotus obliquusSafety
End Stage Renal Disease after Long-Term Ingestion of Chaga Mushroom
Lee S · J Korean Medical Science · 2020
Population: 49-year-old man, prolonged use of chaga powder (~4 years)
Presented with end-stage renal disease; biopsy showed chronic interstitial nephritis with oxalate deposits; the chaga contained 14.2 g oxalate/100 g.
Goal:
A safety signal — reinforces the risk of chronic kidney disease from oxalate load; caution in those with renal risk factors.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewShiitake Lentinula edodesCancer (adjunct)
Lentinan as immunotherapeutic for lung cancer: review of 12 years clinical studies in China
Zhang Y · J Cancer Res Clin Oncol · 2018
Population: 38 RCTs, 3,117 lung cancer patients (China)
Adding lentinan to chemotherapy raised the average response rate from 43.3% to 56.9% (RR 0.79, CI 0.74–0.85) and improved quality of life.
Goal:
Adjunctive use (not standalone); almost all trials are from Chinese-language databases — a concern for publication/quality bias.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewShiitake Lentinula edodesCancer
Lentinan for treating different types of cancers: review of 12 years clinical studies in China
Zhang M · Prog Mol Biol Transl Sci · 2019
Population: 135 studies, 9,474 cancer cases (lung, stomach, colon and others)
Reports a consistent benefit of lentinan as an adjunct for quality of life and chemo/radiotherapy efficacy across various cancer types.
Goal:
Adjunct only; from Chinese databases (CNKI/VIP/Wanfang); heterogeneous designs limit the strength of the evidence.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Shiitake Lentinula edodesImmune · HPV
AHCC Supplementation to Support Immune Function to Clear Persistent HPV Infections
Smith JA · Frontiers in Oncology · 2022
Population: 50 women over age 30 with persistent high-risk HPV
AHCC (shiitake mycelium extract) 3 g/day for 6 months cleared HPV in 63.6% of the treatment group versus 10.5% on placebo; well tolerated.
Goal:
A mycelium extract (AHCC) rather than lentinan itself; a small single-center study needing replication.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Shiitake Lentinula edodesCholesterol
Modulation of gut microbiota by a β-D-glucan-enriched extract from Lentinula edodes
Morales D · European Journal of Nutrition · 2021
Population: 52 adults with mild untreated hypercholesterolemia
A shiitake beta-glucan extract (3.5 g/day, 8 weeks) produced no significant change in lipids/cholesterol or inflammatory markers versus placebo, but did modulate the microbiome.
Goal:
A negative finding for cholesterol-lowering in humans; tempers the hypocholesterolemia claims from animal data.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewShiitake Lentinula edodesImmune
Effects of fungal beta-glucans on health - a systematic review of RCTs
Vlassopoulou M · Food & Function · 2021
Population: 34 RCTs of fungal beta-glucan (including shiitake)
The main consistent effect is immunomodulation (fewer/milder respiratory infections, improved allergy and mood); cell-level immune changes were inconsistent; no side effects from the glucan.
Goal:
Mixed mushroom sources (not exclusively shiitake); calls for dose standardization and mechanistic studies.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Shiitake Lentinula edodesImmune
Modulation of T Regulatory and Dendritic Cell Phenotypes after Bifidobacterium, AHCC and Azithromycin
Chowdhury AH · Nutrients · 2019
Population: 40 healthy male volunteers
AHCC (shiitake mycelium) combined with a probiotic shifted dendritic cell phenotypes toward an anti-inflammatory profile after antibiotics; cytokine differences between groups were not significant.
Goal:
A small mechanistic pilot; the combined design makes it hard to isolate the shiitake effect.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Maitake Grifola frondosaCancer (support)
Effect of Maitake D-fraction in advanced laryngeal/pharyngeal cancers during chemoradiotherapy
Hu Q · Acta Biochimica Polonica · 2022
Population: 141 patients with advanced squamous laryngeal/pharyngeal cancer on chemoradiotherapy
Oral D-fraction reduced severe chemoradiotherapy side effects and improved overall quality-of-life scores versus placebo, with more patients returning to baseline after 6 months.
Goal:
The strongest human study for maitake; supportive/quality-of-life endpoints (not tumor control); single-center, needs replication.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewMaitake Grifola frondosaCancer
Antitumor activities of Grifola frondosa (Maitake) polysaccharide: a meta-analysis of preclinical evidence
Zhao F · J Ethnopharmacology · 2021
Population: 24 animal studies (in-vivo models)
Maitake polysaccharide significantly inhibited tumor growth, improved remission rate (OR 25.59) and immune markers (CD4, IL-2, IL-12, TNF-α).
Goal:
Animal data only; the authors note low study quality and biases; explicitly framed as a basis for future trials.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalMaitake Grifola frondosaImmune
GFPBW1, a β-glucan from Grifola frondosa as vaccine adjuvant: APC activation
He X · Acta Pharmacologica Sinica · 2024
Population: Mouse and cell models (vaccine + B16-OVA tumor)
A purified maitake beta-glucan (GFPBW1) activated antigen-presenting cells via Dectin-1/Syk/NF-κB, increased antibody titers and improved tumor suppression as a vaccine adjuvant.
Goal:
Mechanistic/preclinical; supports adjuvant potential, not a human therapeutic claim.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalMaitake Grifola frondosaCancer
Antitumoral and antimetastatic activity of Maitake D-Fraction in triple-negative breast cancer cells
Alonso EN · Oncotarget · 2018
Population: Triple-negative breast cancer cells MDA-MB-231; mouse xenograft
D-fraction reduced proliferation, migration and metastatic potential (raised E-cadherin/β-catenin, lowered MMP-2/-9) and suppressed tumor growth in xenografts.
Goal:
Cell-line and mouse data only; no human evidence for breast cancer.
Literature reviewMaitake Grifola frondosaCancer · Review
The biological activities of the antitumor drug Grifola frondosa polysaccharide
He Y · Prog Mol Biol Transl Sci · 2019
Population: Synthesis of 108 studies
Reviews antitumor, immune-balancing, antidiabetic and lipid-lowering activity; approved in China (2010) as an adjunct cancer drug (oral or injectable).
Goal:
The China approval is as an adjunct; the efficacy data are mostly preclinical/from Chinese databases.
Animal studyMaitake Grifola frondosaImmune
CD3ε immune restorative ability of Maitake Pro4x in immunosuppressed mice
Aguilera-Braico DM · BMC Research Notes · 2022
Population: Immunosuppressed BALB/c mice (dexamethasone)
D-fraction Pro4X (5 mg/kg) restored ~43% of the suppressed T/NK cell populations and increased granulocytes in the lymph nodes.
Goal:
An animal-only proof of concept for immune restoration.
Literature reviewBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityBeta-glucan · Mechanism
Immunomodulatory Effect and Biological Significance of β-Glucans
Zhong X · Pharmaceutics · 2023
Population: Review
Beta-glucan acts as a "biological response modifier": it promotes dendritic cell maturation, cytokine secretion and regulation of adaptive immunity; activity depends on source, molecular weight, branching and spatial structure.
Goal:
A narrative, non-quantitative review; covers cereal and microbial/fungal beta-glucan.
Literature reviewBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityBeta-glucan · Mechanism
Dectin-1 Signaling Update: New Perspectives for Trained Immunity
Mata-Martínez P · Frontiers in Immunology · 2022
Population: Immunological review
Dectin-1 is the main receptor (a C-type lectin) for beta-glucan on myeloid cells; glucan binding triggers phagocytosis, ROS and cytokine production, and is essential for initiating "trained immunity".
Goal:
A mechanistic review; the outcome is structure- and ligand-dependent (can be pro-inflammatory or regulatory).
Literature reviewBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityBeta-glucan · Mechanism
Fungal polysaccharides
Xiao Z · Advances in Pharmacology · 2019
Population: Review
Most antitumor fungal beta-glucans share a β-(1→3) backbone with β-(1→6) branches and act through several immune receptors — Dectin-1, complement receptor 3 (CR3) and TLR-2/6.
Goal:
Directly establishes the Dectin-1/CR3 mechanism; at the review level.
Animal studyBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityBeta-glucan · Trained immunity
Modulation of Myelopoiesis Progenitors Is an Integral Component of Trained Immunity
Mitroulis I · Cell · 2018
Population: C57BL/6 mice; bone marrow progenitor cells
Beta-glucan (a prototypical trained-immunity agonist) expanded myeloid progenitors via IL-1β and GM-CSF with metabolic reprogramming, conferring a beneficial secondary response and protection from chemotherapy-induced bone marrow suppression.
Goal:
A foundational mechanistic paper; an animal model, not human.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityCardio-metabolic
Effects of Oat Beta-Glucan on Lipid Profiles in Hypercholesterolemic Adults: meta-analysis of RCTs
Yu J · Nutrients · 2022
Population: 13 RCTs, 927 hypercholesterolemic adults
Oat beta-glucan significantly reduced total cholesterol (−0.24 mmol/L) and LDL (−0.27), with no significant change in triglycerides or HDL.
Goal:
The evidence is for cereal beta-glucan (oats), not fungal; the mechanism (viscous fiber, bile acid binding) differs from the immune-receptor pathway.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityCardio-metabolic
Oat supplementation and cardiovascular disease risk markers: meta-analysis of RCTs
Llanaj E · European Journal of Nutrition · 2022
Population: 74 RCTs, ~4,937 adults
Oat/cereal beta-glucan interventions lowered total cholesterol (−0.42), LDL (−0.29), glucose (−0.25) and slightly improved BMI/waist circumference; inflammatory markers were inconsistent.
Goal:
81% of the RCTs had some bias concerns; again cereal beta-glucan — generalization to fungal beta-glucan is not direct.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityMycelium vs. fruiting body
Bioactive Metabolites from Fruiting Body and Mycelia of Oyster Mushroom
Brazkova M · Foods · 2022
Population: Oyster mushroom (Pleurotus ostreatus): fruiting body vs. mycelial biomass
Beta-glucan content was 31.66% in the fruiting body versus 12.04% in the mycelial biomass — about 2.6 times higher in the fruiting body. Water extracts showed the highest polyphenol content and antioxidant activity.
Goal:
A single-species comparison; directly supports the claim that fruiting body > mycelium in beta-glucan, but one species and one lab.
Literature reviewBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityMycelium vs. fruiting body
Edible Mushrooms: Novel Agents to Combat Metabolic Syndrome
Tung YT · Current Pharmaceutical Design · 2020
Population: Review
Reviews therapeutic properties (anti-obesity, cardioprotective, antidiabetic) across different mushroom fractions, and explicitly distinguishes between the fruiting body and mycelium and their extracts.
Goal:
A broad review; treats the fruiting body and mycelium as distinct source materials but does not rigorously quantify beta-glucan yields.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityMycelium vs. fruiting body
Genome Survey and Transcriptome Analysis on Mycelia and Primordia
Lu YP · BioMed Research International · 2020
Population: Mycelium vs. primordia (fruiting body buds)
Genes in the polysaccharide/beta-glucan and steroid biosynthesis pathways are regulated differently between mycelium and primordia, with the biosynthesis pathways more active in the fruiting-body-formation stage.
Goal:
Mechanistic/genomic evidence for developmental-stage-dependent differences; does not measure beta-glucan in the final product.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityExtract vs. powder
High pressure pre-treatment and hot water extraction of mushroom polysaccharide
Tepsongkroh B · Food Chemistry: X · 2023
Population: Extraction (laboratory)
Hot-water extraction yielded protein-bound polysaccharides with β-glycosidic bonds; adding high-pressure pre-treatment raised crude polysaccharide yield by 2–12% and beta-glucan content by 15–20% versus hot water alone.
Goal:
Demonstrates that processing/extraction concentrates beta-glucan; laboratory scale, one mushroom.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityExtract vs. powder
Polysaccharides from Volvariella Mushroom: Extraction and Biological Activities
Sangthong S · Journal of Fungi (Basel) · 2022
Population: Comparison of extraction methods
Among shaken hot-water, microwave and ultrasound extraction — shaken hot water gave both the highest yield (15.58%) and the highest beta-glucan content (18.80%), along with the strongest antioxidant activity.
Goal:
Supports hot-water extraction for recovering beta-glucan; a method comparison, not human bioavailability.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityExtract vs. powder
Improved Extraction of Water-Soluble Polysaccharide from Gamma-Irradiated Shiitake
Akram K · Journal of Food Science · 2017
Population: Extraction (laboratory)
Hot-water extraction yielded 2.01% soluble polysaccharide from untreated dried shiitake; pre-treatment raised the yield to 7.17% and purity from 78.8% to 85.6% — illustrating how much active material is "locked" in the raw material without processing.
Goal:
Shows that dried raw material releases limited soluble polysaccharide versus a processed extract; pre-treatment also lowers molecular weight.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityBioavailability
Mushroom polysaccharide-based self-nanoemulsifying delivery system (curcumin, quercetin)
Khursheed R · Int J Biological Macromolecules · 2021
Population: Laboratory (Caco-2 cells)
A reishi-extract polysaccharide used as a carrier converted a liquid nano-emulsion into a solid form and raised compound release from <20% (unprocessed) to >90%, improving the dissolution and permeability of poorly bioavailable compounds.
Goal:
Concerns the polysaccharide as a carrier/excipient (not absorption of beta-glucan itself); illustrates formulation principles rather than direct absorption.
Laboratory / in-vitro / analyticalBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityQuality · Adulteration
Comparative Study of Chaga Dietary Supplements Using Complementary Analytical Techniques
Windsor C · Int J Molecular Sciences · 2025
Population: Commercial chaga supplements vs. authentic wild chaga
Using HPTLC, LC-MS, NMR, beta-glucan quantification and iodine-starch tests, authentic wild chaga was shown to contain characteristic triterpenoids/melanin, whereas many "mycelium on fermented grain" products were high in starch and lacked authentic markers.
Goal:
The strongest citation for the grain/starch adulteration/mislabeling point; the authors are affiliated with a mushroom-extract company (Nammex) — a possible conflict of interest to disclose; the methods are multi-analytical and reproducible.
Literature reviewBeta-glucan, mycelium and qualityQuality · Standardization
Lion's Mane (Hericium erinaceus): A Neuroprotective Fungus — A Narrative Review
Contato AG · Nutrients · 2025
Population: Review
Summarizes bioactives (polysaccharides, hericenones, erinacines) and explicitly concludes that clinical validation is still limited and that standardization of extraction methods and pharmacokinetic/bioavailability characterization are needed before firm health claims.
Goal:
A narrative review; supports the "standardization gap / claims outpace the evidence" point and presents no new analytical data.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Colorectal (adjunct)
Adjuvant immunochemotherapy with PSK for curatively resected colorectal cancer: a meta-analysis
Sakamoto J et al. · Cancer Immunol Immunother · 2005
Population: 1,094 colorectal cancer patients after resection, 3 pivotal randomized trials
Adding PSK to chemotherapy improved overall survival (RR 0.71, CI 0.55–0.90; P=0.006) and disease-free survival (RR 0.72, CI 0.58–0.90).
Goal:
The three trials were Japanese and predated modern oxaliplatin regimens; PSK was combined with older drugs (mitomycin/5-FU/UFT).
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Gastric (adjunct)
Adjuvant immunochemotherapy with PSK for curatively resected gastric cancer
Oba K et al. · Cancer Immunol Immunother · 2006
Population: 8,009 gastric cancer patients after resection, 8 pivotal randomized trials
PSK with chemotherapy modestly improved survival versus chemotherapy alone (pooled HR 0.88, CI 0.79–0.98).
Goal:
A smaller effect than in colorectal cancer; all trials were Asian (Japan) and mostly on 1980s–90s chemotherapy regimens.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer (adjunct)
Efficacy of Yun Zhi (Trametes versicolor) on survival in cancer patients: systematic review and meta-analysis
Eliza WL et al. · Recent Pat Inflamm Allergy Drug Discov · 2012
Population: 13 clinical trials in cancer patients (mixed tumor types)
Yun Zhi (turkey tail) conferred a significant survival advantage, with an absolute ~9% reduction in 5-year mortality versus standard treatment alone.
Goal:
Published in a low-profile patents journal; the trials were heterogeneous, mostly Asian and of variable quality/blinding.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer (adjunct)
Trametes versicolor and Related Products as Adjunct Therapy for Cancers: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of RCTs
Zhong L et al. · Frontiers in Pharmacology · 2019
Population: 23 randomized trials, 4,246 cancer patients
T. versicolor products as an adjunct were associated with improved survival and quality of life without a significant increase in side effects.
Goal:
Considerable clinical heterogeneity across tumor types/protocols; many trials are old or of low methodological quality.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Gastrointestinal (adjunct)
Can PSK improve efficacy and safety in gastrointestinal cancer? Systematic review and network meta-analysis
Ma Y et al. · Oncotarget · 2017
Population: 23 randomized trials, 10,684 gastrointestinal cancer patients
PSK significantly increased overall survival (1–5 years) and disease-free survival (1–7 years) without an increase in side effects; PSK+chemotherapy was the preferred arm.
Goal:
Mostly Asian trials; Oncotarget's editorial standing in this period is contested; the benefit is concentrated in colon and gastric cancer.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Lung (adjunct)
PSK and Trametes versicolor extracts for lung cancer: a systematic review
Fritz H et al. · Integrative Cancer Therapies · 2015
Population: 28 studies (6 randomized, 5 non-randomized controlled, 17 preclinical)
Several trials reported improved survival and/or symptom relief with PSK/Coriolus alongside standard treatment in lung cancer; well tolerated.
Goal:
A narrative synthesis (no pooled effect); the RCT evidence is limited and mostly old, modestly sized Asian trials.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Turkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Colorectal (adjunct)
Adjuvant PSK plus tegafur/uracil in stage II/III colorectal cancer: randomized controlled trial
Ohwada S et al. · Dis Colon Rectum · 2003
Population: 207 stage II/III colorectal cancer patients after resection
Oral PSK added to UFT improved disease-free and overall survival with a reasonable safety profile.
Goal:
Japan only, open-label, a medium sample; the UFT regimen is not standard outside Asia.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Turkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Colorectal (adjunct)
Adjuvant PSK for colon cancer in relation to oncogenic beta-catenin activation
Yamashita K et al. · Dis Colon Rectum · 2007
Population: 202 colon cancer patients (5-FU + PSK vs. 5-FU alone)
The survival benefit from adding PSK appeared to depend on tumor beta-catenin/NF-κB activation status — a hint of an effect in a molecular subgroup.
Goal:
A subgroup/biomarker analysis in a medium single-institution cohort; hypothesis-generating, not confirmatory.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Turkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Colorectal (adjunct)
Adjuvant UFT/LV Plus PSK in Stage II/III Colorectal Cancer (randomized phase II)
Ogawa H et al. · Anticancer Research · 2024
Population: 186 stage II/III colorectal cancer patients (UFT/LV vs. UFT/LV+PSK, 6 vs. 12 months)
A recent randomized (phase II) trial comparing UFT/LV with or without PSK; the primary endpoint was 3-year disease-free survival.
Goal:
One of the few newer randomized trials, but a small phase II, Japan only, and PSK's contribution beyond UFT/LV remains uncertain.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Turkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Lung · Immune
Trametes versicolor polysaccharide peptide (PSP) slows progression of advanced NSCLC
Tsang KW et al. · Respiratory Medicine · 2003
Population: 68 advanced NSCLC lung cancer patients after standard treatment (34 per arm)
PSP for 28 days improved leukocyte/neutrophil counts, serum IgG/IgM and body fat percentage, and was associated with slowed disease progression versus placebo.
Goal:
Very small, a short intervention (28 days), a single center in Hong Kong; underpowered for survival endpoints.
Observational / cohort studyTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · Gastric (adjunct)
PSK prolonged overall survival in gastric cancer patients (non-Japanese Asian cohort)
Wang TY et al. · Medicine (Baltimore) · 2022
Population: 6,475 matched gastric cancer patients (1,295 PSK vs. 5,180 controls), Taiwan NHI database
Adding PSK to adjuvant chemotherapy was associated with longer median survival (6.49 vs. 3.59 years; adjusted HR 0.76, P<0.0001).
Goal:
A retrospective claims-database cohort — likely residual confounding (PSK users may differ substantially); not randomized.
Clinical trial (non-randomized / early phase)Turkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorImmune · Safety · Cancer
Phase 1 Clinical Trial of Trametes versicolor in Women with Breast Cancer
Torkelson CJ et al. · ISRN Oncology · 2012
Population: 11 enrolled / 9 completed, women after chemo/radiotherapy for breast cancer (3, 6, 9 g/day)
Up to 9 g/day was safe and well tolerated, with trends toward increased lymphocyte count, NK cell activity and CD8+/CD19+ cells.
Goal:
Tiny (n=9 completers), no placebo arm, the immune changes were non-significant trends; a safety/feasibility study only.
Literature reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorImmune · Microbiome
Control of Cancer Stem Cells and the Gut Microbiome by Trametes-Derived PSP (Review)
Wu JM et al. · Int J Medicinal Mushrooms · 2016
Population: Review (lab/animal and limited human data)
Summarizes antitumor and immune-balancing effects of PSP, possible elimination of prostate cancer stem cells, and prebiotic control of the gut microbiome.
Goal:
A narrative review, not primary human data; mechanistic/preclinical emphasis with limited clinical support.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Turkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorImmune · Microbiome
Effects of PSP from Trametes versicolor and amoxicillin on the gut microbiome of healthy volunteers
Pallav K et al. · Gut Microbes · 2014
Population: 24 healthy volunteers (PSP vs. amoxicillin vs. control), 8 weeks
PSP acted as a prebiotic and changed gut bacterial composition (e.g. Bifidobacterium/Lactobacillus), in contrast to the disruptive effect of amoxicillin.
Goal:
A small pilot in healthy adults (not cancer patients); short duration and exploratory microbiome endpoints; one of the only human microbiome trials for turkey tail.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorSafety · Cancer
Coriolus (Trametes) versicolor to reduce chemo/radiotherapy adverse effects in colorectal cancer (Cochrane)
Pilkington K et al. · Cochrane Database Syst Rev · 2022
Population: Colorectal cancer patients on chemo/radiotherapy (search through April 2022)
The most rigorous synthesis to date found insufficient, very-low-certainty evidence to determine whether Coriolus reduces side effects or affects survival.
Goal:
The central honest counterweight — a high-quality Cochrane review concluding that the evidence base is too weak/low-quality for firm conclusions.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewTurkey tail Trametes (Coriolus) versicolorCancer · HPV (topical)
Trametes versicolor-based vaginal gel on HPV clearance and cervical dysplasia — scoping review
Højen IB et al. · BMC Women's Health · 2026
Population: 5 studies (one RCT n=91, a sub-analysis n=41, 3 cohorts)
A C. versicolor-based vaginal gel was associated with higher HPV clearance and regression of cervical dysplasia (76.1–84.9% vs. 40.8–64.5% in controls), without serious side effects.
Goal:
A scoping review of mostly small/observational studies with one small RCT; the formulation and route (topical) differ from oral PSK/PSP; preliminary, large RCTs are needed.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Reishi Ganoderma lucidumMood · Stress · Energy
Reishi (Ganoderma lucidum) Supplementation on Psychological Stress and Fitness in Female College Students
Mitra S et al. · Int J Medicinal Mushrooms · 2024
Population: 78 sedentary female students (~age 20), 3 arms: 500 mg / 1000 mg / placebo, 30 days
The group receiving 1000 mg/day showed significant improvement in anxiety, depression, energy and well-being, along with improved cardiorespiratory fitness (VO2max, PWC170), versus placebo.
Goal:
A small, short (30-day) study, a single population (young women); the psychological endpoints were secondary in a fitness-focused design; no active comparator.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Cordyceps CordycepsSleep · Mood
Cordyceps as Adjuvant to Duloxetine for Insomnia in Patients With Depression
Zhou J et al. · Frontiers in Psychiatry · 2021
Population: 59 depression patients with insomnia (28 cordyceps + duloxetine, 31 placebo + duloxetine), 6 weeks
Adding cordyceps to duloxetine did not improve insomnia (AIS) or depression (HAMD-17) versus placebo; the placebo arm even showed a slightly larger reduction in AIS. Well tolerated.
Goal:
A negative finding. A small single-center sample, ~19% dropout, fixed dose/short duration; measured only as an add-on to an antidepressant, not as standalone treatment.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Cordyceps CordycepsSleep
Fermentation broth of Cordyceps for primary insomnia: a randomized clinical trial
Zhao S et al. · Frontiers in Neurology · 2025
Population: 90 patients with primary insomnia (45 cordyceps fermentation juice 150 mL/day vs. 45 placebo), 28 days
The Cordyceps fermentation-juice group showed a significantly larger reduction in total PSQI score and most subscales (quality, sleep latency, duration, efficiency) versus placebo on days 14 and 28.
Goal:
Positive but modest and short-term; a single fermentation product, 28-day follow-up, no objective sleep measures (polysomnography); in a Chinese-medicine setting.
Literature reviewCordyceps CordycepsEnergy · Performance
Ergogenic and Post-Exercise Recovery Effects of Cordyceps Supplementation in Humans — A Narrative Review
Jędrejko M et al. · Nutrients · 2026
Population: Synthesis of 5 human intervention studies, 321 participants aged 16–35
Reviews the evidence for cordyceps improving performance and recovery in healthy people; the conclusion — the human evidence is still limited and inconsistent across the small number of trials.
Goal:
Narrative (not a quantitative meta-analysis); a very small evidence base, heterogeneous protocols, mostly healthy young people.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Cordyceps CordycepsEnergy · Performance
Cordyceps Improves Tolerance to High-Intensity Exercise After Acute and Chronic Supplementation
Hirsch KR et al. · J Dietary Supplements · 2016
Population: 28 healthy adults (~age 23), 10 continued to 3 weeks
After one week no significant effects were found on VO2max, ventilatory threshold, time to exhaustion or power output. After 3 weeks VO2max improved significantly in the cordyceps-blend group (+4.8 mL/kg/min, p=0.042) but not in placebo.
Goal:
A small sample, especially the 3-week arm (n=10); the product is a multi-mushroom blend — it cannot be attributed to cordyceps alone; first-week results were null.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Cordyceps CordycepsEnergy · Performance
Cordyceps + Ganoderma lucidum Supplement and Physiological Responses to Maximal Exercise
Tsuk S et al. · Int J Medicinal Mushrooms · 2018
Population: 96 physical-education students (~age 26), low/high dose/placebo, 28–33 days
Tested a commercial cordyceps/Ganoderma supplement in graded VO2max tests and a Wingate anaerobic test; the PubMed abstract described the design but did not include the numerical outcome values.
Goal:
A combined product (cordyceps cannot be separated from reishi); the effect magnitudes were not captured in the abstract — direction/size should be verified from the full text.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewCordyceps CordycepsEnergy · Performance · Lungs (COPD)
Bailing capsule (Cordyceps-derived) on chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a meta-analysis
Ma G et al. · Pharmaceutical Biology · 2024
Population: 27 RCTs; COPD patients (cordyceps-derived Bailing capsule + standard treatment vs. standard)
The meta-analysis reported significant improvement in measures including lung function and exercise tolerance/quality of life when the Bailing capsule was added to standard COPD treatment.
Goal:
Disease-specific (COPD), not general fatigue/performance; the "add-on" design confounds attribution; Chinese-medicine RCTs with known bias risk; the relevance to "energy/performance" is indirect.
Animal studyLion's mane Hericium erinaceusMood · Sleep
Hericium erinaceus mycelium ameliorates anxiety induced by continuous sleep disturbance in vivo
Li TJ et al. · BMC Complement Med Ther · 2021
Population: Rodent model of continuous sleep disturbance
Lion's mane mycelium (containing erinacine/hericenone-type compounds linked to NGF/BDNF) reduced anxiety-like behavior induced by chronic sleep disruption in animals.
Goal:
A preclinical animal-only study; no human data; the mechanism/dose cannot be translated directly to a human dose.
Animal studyLion's mane Hericium erinaceusSleep
Hericium erinaceus extracts alter behavioral rhythm in mice
Furuta S et al. · Biomedical Research (Tokyo) · 2016
Population: Mice
A water extract of lion's mane advanced the sleep-wake cycle (circadian activity) and modestly affected activity timing; an ethanol extract had only a limited effect.
Goal:
A preclinical circadian animal study; small, mechanistic; the effects are modest and extract-dependent; not a human/sleep outcome.
Literature reviewLion's mane Hericium erinaceusCognition · Neural
Hericium erinaceus in Neurodegenerative Diseases: From Bench to Bedside and Beyond
Brandalise F et al. · J Fungi (Basel) · 2023
Population: Review (in-vitro, animal and limited clinical data)
Summarizes the effects of lion's mane/erinacines on production of neurotrophic factors (NGF/BDNF) and the potential in Alzheimer's, MCI, depression and Parkinson's; explicitly notes that only a few clinical trials exist.
Goal:
A non-systematic review; the human evidence is sparse; the authors call for larger/better clinical trials.
Animal studyLion's mane Hericium erinaceusCognition
Boosting Memory by an Ergothioneine-Rich Hericium erinaceus Primordium Extract in Aging Mice
Roda E et al. · Biology (Basel) · 2023
Population: Aging mice
An ergothioneine-rich lion's mane primordium extract prevented decline in recognition memory in a mouse aging model, linked to anti-inflammatory/antioxidant mechanisms.
Goal:
Preclinical only; no human data; the results may not translate to human cognition.
Animal studyLion's mane Hericium erinaceusCognition
Erinacine A-Enriched Hericium erinaceus Mycelium Delays Age-Related Cognitive Decline in SAMP8 Mice
Lee LY et al. · Nutrients · 2021
Population: 3-month-old SAMP8 mice, 3 dose groups
Erinacine A-enriched mycelium improved learning/memory (avoidance tests) and delayed brain-aging markers in a dose-dependent manner.
Goal:
Preclinical only; a specific erinacine A-enriched product; no generalization to humans.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Other mushrooms and blendsCognition · Mood
Vitamin D-Enriched Mushrooms and Vitamin D3 on Cognitive Performance and Mood in Healthy Elderly
Zajac IT et al. · Nutrients · 2020
Population: 436 healthy adults (60+); 4 arms: vitamin D3, D2-enriched mushrooms, regular mushroom, placebo; 6 months
The primary endpoints were vitamin D status and cognition/mood; the interventions (mushrooms/vitamin D) produced no clear benefit on mood versus placebo.
Goal:
Largely negative for mood. The mushroom here is a regular button mushroom used as a vitamin D carrier, not a "medicinal mushroom"; mood was a secondary endpoint.
Randomized controlled trial (RCT)Other mushrooms and blendsSleep · Mood · Fatigue
Adaptogenic Effects of a Mushroom Blend Supplement on Stress, Fatigue, and Sleep
Hisamuddin AS et al. · Brain and Behavior · 2025
Population: 50 adults, a mushroom blend vs. placebo; measured at baseline, 6 and 12 weeks
A medicinal-mushroom blend was tested against placebo on psychological and physiological stress, fatigue and sleep measures over 12 weeks (an adaptogenic/well-being framing).
Goal:
A small sample (n=50); an industry affiliation (authors from the product's manufacturer); a proprietary multi-species blend limits attribution to a single mushroom; the effect direction/size should be verified from the full text.
Literature reviewChinese medicine and methodologyChinese medicine · Ethnopharmacology · Cardiac
Cordyceps: Alleviating ischemic cardiovascular and cerebrovascular injury — a comprehensive review
Li Y et al. · J Ethnopharmacology · 2024
Population: Review (preclinical + clinical literature)
Positions cordyceps (Dong Chong Xia Cao) as a long-standing "nourishing" tonic in Chinese medicine, and reviews chemistry, pharmacology, clinical application and safety for ischemic cardiac/cerebral injury.
Goal:
Explicitly draws on Chinese databases (CNKI, Wanfang) alongside PubMed; useful for the traditional rationale but a narrative review, not a quantitative synthesis.
Literature reviewChinese medicine and methodologyChinese medicine · Immune · Cancer
COVID-19 and Cancer: The Potential of Trametes versicolor to Combat Global Health Challenges
Jędrzejewski T et al. · Int J Molecular Sciences · 2023
Population: Review (in-vitro, animal and clinical)
Documents the use of Coriolus/Trametes versicolor (Yun Zhi) in Chinese herbal medicine for over 2000 years, and reviews PSP and PSK as immune-balancing/anticancer agents already in adjunctive use in some countries.
Goal:
Good for the classical rationale and the PSK/PSP link, but mixes preclinical and clinical data and is not systematic.
Literature reviewChinese medicine and methodologyChinese medicine · Review
Hericium erinaceus: an edible mushroom with medicinal values
Khan MA et al. · J Complement Integr Med · 2013
Population: Review
Reviews lion's mane (Hou Tou Gu), with a long history of use in Chinese medicine and beta-glucan-based anticancer, immune-balancing, lipid-lowering, antioxidant and neuroprotective activity.
Goal:
A review of mostly preclinical activity; the traditional-use context is presented as a claim and not critically appraised.
Animal studyChinese medicine and methodologyChinese medicine · Metabolic liver
Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharides alleviate non-alcoholic fatty liver disease by modulating gut microbiota
Zhao H et al. · J Ethnopharmacology · 2025
Population: Mouse model of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease
Positions reishi (Lingzhi) as a "revered Chinese medicinal herb" for use in metabolic diseases, and provides mechanistic support for its polysaccharides in NAFLD (TLR4/NF-κB/AMPK pathways).
Goal:
An ethnopharmacological anchor for Lingzhi, but a preclinical animal study — human efficacy cannot be inferred from it.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewChinese medicine and methodologyResearch quality · Country-of-origin bias (TCM)
Do certain countries produce only positive results? A systematic review of controlled trials
Vickers A et al. · Controlled Clinical Trials · 1998
Population: 1,085 acupuncture abstracts + a cross-country comparison
Trials (acupuncture and others) originating in China, Japan, Russia and Taiwan were almost always positive, while trials from England were not — evidence of a "country-of-origin" bias.
Goal:
A fundamental caveat for interpreting any efficacy signal of Chinese origin; directly relevant to mushroom trials published locally.
Literature reviewChinese medicine and methodologyResearch quality · TCM
Review of randomised controlled trials of traditional Chinese medicine
Tang JL et al. · BMJ · 1999
Population: Review of randomized trials in traditional Chinese medicine
Found that the methodological quality of RCTs in Chinese medicine was generally low (poor randomization, blinding and reporting), which limits the reliability of sweeping positive conclusions.
Goal:
The canonical statement that RCT quality in Chinese medicine is weak; widely cited as the reference assessment.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewChinese medicine and methodologyResearch quality · Country-of-origin bias
A meta-analysis of acupuncture techniques for smoking cessation
White AR et al. · Tobacco Control · 1999
Population: Randomized trials of acupuncture vs. sham acupuncture
Acupuncture was not superior to sham acupuncture (OR ~1.0–1.3); subgroup analyses by country of origin and journal status showed generally poor quality and no real effect.
Goal:
Included because it explicitly examines country-of-origin/journal status as effect variables — a methodological template for detecting geography-dependent positivity (Chinese/Asian origin).
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewChinese medicine and methodologyResearch quality · CNKI (TCM)
Reporting quality of RCTs on coronary heart disease treated with TCM: a systematic review
Fan FF et al. · PLoS One · 2014
Population: Chinese-medicine trials for CHD indexed in CNKI (2006–2011)
Applying CONSORT 2010 to RCTs from Chinese databases revealed substantial reporting deficiencies (randomization, allocation concealment, blinding and sample-size calculation).
Goal:
A recent, database-specific confirmation that the reporting quality of local Chinese trials is still limited.
Meta-analysis / systematic reviewChinese medicine and methodologyChinese medicine · Kidney (Cochrane)
Cordyceps (a traditional Chinese medicine) for treating chronic kidney disease
Zhang HW et al. · Cochrane Database Syst Rev · 2014
Population: Chronic kidney disease patients (randomized/quasi-randomized trials)
Searched Chinese databases (CBM, CMCC, TCMLARS and others) and reported an apparent benefit of cordyceps on kidney function/proteinuria, but graded the evidence as low-quality and at high risk of bias — and therefore not reliable.
Goal:
A clear example of a large local literature that appears positive but is downgraded at the evidence level when methodological rigor is applied.